Hey —
Welcome to Issue #0 of The Defensible File. Once a week I read the agency updates and tell you three things: what changed, which file it hits, and how to keep it from turning into a finding.
The short version this month: Fannie and Freddie both published on Nov 4, FHA's credit-score rewrite has a Jan 1 start date you should prep for now, and VA had no new origination circulars (just one servicing item). There's also a House bill that would raise the IRRRL funding fee. It is not law, but your Veterans will ask about it.
— Kevin
1) Fannie Mae: SEL-2026-10 Selling Guide update (Nov 4, 2026)
Source: Announcement SEL-2026-10 · PDF
What changed
Occupancy: Fannie aligned the occupancy-type language in the Guide (B2-1.1-01, Occupancy Types) with the occupancy language in the security instruments. It says this is a clarification meant to reduce occupancy misrepresentation defects. Effective immediately.
ADUs in condo projects: accessory dwelling units are now allowed in eligible condo projects (B2-3-04, B4-2.1-03). The UAD 3.6 Policy Supplement was updated to match. Effective immediately.
Community Seconds and grants: reorganized and clarified (B3-4.3-06, B5-5.1-01), including lender responsibilities for reviewing Community Seconds programs and a refined Community Seconds Checklist.
VantageScore 4.0: LL-2026-06 is now in the Guide (B3-5.1-01), and VantageScore 4.0 use is extended to manually underwritten loans and DU Version 12.1 casefiles.
Premium recapture (whole loans): if a whole loan with a net negative LLPA pays off within 120 days of purchase, the reimbursement is the negative LLPA plus a 50 bp processing fee (C1-1-01). Effective immediately.
What it means for the file
Occupancy is a defect magnet. Make sure your occupancy evidence (application, intent to occupy, departure-residence plan, mailing addresses on the credit report and bank statements) tells the same story as the security instrument the borrower signs. Second-home files with rental-looking facts are where this bites.
Community Seconds/DPA: get the provider's program review on file and use Fannie's refined checklist. "We've always used this program" is not a review.
Secondary/pricing desk: the 120-day payoff rule is a cost to your company, not the borrower. It matters for early-refi solicitation and for any loan where a quick payoff is foreseeable.
2) Fannie Mae: LL-2026-09, Manual Underwriting Eligibility (Nov 4, 2026)
Source: Selling Policy Communications · LL-2026-09 PDF
What changed: The Eligibility Matrix for manually underwritten loans is revised for loans delivered to Fannie on or after Feb 22, 2027. It aligns minimum credit scores for fixed and ARM loans, sets consistent credit score and reserve requirements for 2–4-unit principal residences and for cash-out refis, and combines all manual underwriting requirements (including HomeReady and HomeStyle) into one matrix.
Full Lender Letter: LL-2026-09 PDF. Compare its matrix with your overlays before Feb 22.
What it means for the file: If you manually underwrite conventional loans, closings in late January 2027 may be delivered after Feb 22, so check which matrix your investor will apply.
3) Freddie Mac: Bulletin 2026-15, Selling Updates (Nov 4, 2026)
Source: Bulletin 2026-15 · PDF
What changed
Equity buyout refinances: "special purpose cash-out" loans used to buy out a co-owner are reclassified as "no cash-out" and renamed equity buyout refinance Mortgages (moved to §4301.4). They now get all no-cash-out LTVs and programs. Proceeds must go first to buy out the co-owner(s). The 12-month joint ownership requirement now includes Seller retention of supporting documentation, and the joint occupancy requirement is removed. Delivery: ULDD Sort ID 368 = "203". Effective immediately.
Third-party asset verification reports are now eligible documentation for depository, securities and retirement accounts, including when assets are used as income (§§5307.1, 5501.3). Effective immediately.
VantageScore 4.0 is now allowed for manually underwritten mortgages, and the Alt FICO Credit Fee in Price is eliminated (Exhibit 19).
Rental income (§5306.1): reorganized. Appraisal rules updated: a non-subject property or departure residence does not need a UAD 3.6 appraisal, and a subject 2–4-unit primary residence needs a UAD 3.6 Traditional Appraisal Report (hybrids aren't allowed for 2–4 units). For a subject 2–4-unit primary or a subject investment property where rental income isn't used to qualify and the appraisal doesn't show gross monthly rent, the Seller may deliver estimated rent from a written borrower statement or Form 65 Section 3a.
ULDD borrower contact data points (email and phone for the primary borrower plus up to four more borrowers) are optional starting Nov 10, 2026.
What it means for the file
Equity buyouts: the file now has to prove 12 months of joint ownership (title or deed history, the prior security instrument), and the closing documents should evidence that the co-owner buyout was the first use of proceeds. Rename your product code and checklist, and confirm ULDD 368 = 203 with post-closing.
Asset reports: if you replace statements with a third-party report, the report still has to support every large deposit you'd otherwise source. Keep the rest of your asset analysis.
Departure residence rent: stop ordering UAD 3.6 appraisals you don't need, but keep the lease and supporting docs your overlays require.
4) FHA: Mortgagee Letter 2026-11, Minimum Decision Credit Score with alternative scores (issued Oct 8; effective for case numbers assigned on/after Jan 1, 2027)
Source: ML 2026-11 (PDF)
Published nine days before this issue's 30-day window, but it starts in six weeks, so it's in.
What changed: FHA adds FICO 10T and VantageScore 4.0 alongside Classic FICO and rewrites how the MDCS is set (Handbook 4000.1 II.A.1.b.ii(A)(3)):
Per model: if there are three scores use the middle, if two use the lower, if one use that one. The Borrower-Level Score is the lowest of the selected scores across the models submitted. The MDCS is the lowest Borrower-Level Score across borrowers.
The same model type(s) must be used for all borrowers. You can't run FICO 10T for one and VantageScore 4.0 for the co-borrower.
The credit report in the case binder must include every model type submitted in the final TOTAL submission.
Tri-merge is still required, minimum score thresholds are unchanged, and an MDCS under 500 is ineligible.
What it means for the file: this is a binder-completeness finding waiting to happen. If your LOS pulls one model but TOTAL received two, the file is deficient. Add a pre-endorsement check: "Score models in final TOTAL = score models on the retained credit report, same models for every borrower."
5) FHA multifamily: ML 2026-12 (Oct 14) and ML 2026-13 (Nov 2)
What changed: Build-to-Rent communities are eligible under multifamily §221(d)(4) and §223(f) (ML 2026-12), and there's a new LIHTC "Express Lane" for qualifying §221(d)(4) new-construction loans (ML 2026-13).
What it means for the file: Nothing for single-family files. Listed so you know it's not something you missed.
6) VA: Circular 26-26-5, Partial Claim payments via Fedwire (Oct 27, 2026)
Source: Circular 26-26-5 (PDF) · VA circulars list
What changed: Servicer instructions for remitting VA Partial Claim payments by Fedwire, with exact field formats. Effective immediately.
What it means for the file: No origination impact. VA's circular list shows no new origination-side circulars in the last 30 days. The most recent ones that matter for originators are 26-24-19 Change 1 (Jun 4, 2026; invoices for itemized fees) and 26-26-1 (Feb 17, 2026; State Fees & Charges Deviations List). Both feed straight into this issue's audit tip.
On the radar (NOT in effect)
H.R. 9237, Take Care of America's Veterans Act. The House passed it by voice vote on Nov 11, 2026. The bill would raise the IRRRL funding fee and change some other VA loan fees. It is not law, but your Veterans will ask about it. The Senate companion (S. 4744) hadn't been voted on as of this writing.
Sources: H.R. 9237 on Congress.gov · Introduced text (govinfo) · ABA Banking Journal, Nov 13, 2026 · S. 4744 on Congress.gov
File tip: don't quote a future fee. Use VA's current funding fee table (Circular 26-23-6, Change 2) until VA issues new guidance.
Audit Tip of the Week: "Show me the invoice."
Missing credit report invoices were on VA's own FFLR deficiency list (2023 LGY lender conference). Since Circular 26-24-19 Change 1 (Jun 4, 2026), you don't upload invoices with the FFLR package, but you still must keep a service-provider invoice for every itemized fee in the file and produce it on request, including for VA Monitoring Unit audits.
Do this Monday: pull your last five closed VA files. For each one, match every Veteran-paid itemized fee on the final CD to (a) an allowable fee in M26-7 Ch. 8 Topic 2 (KnowVA), or the State Deviations List in Circular 26-26-1, and (b) an invoice in the file. Credit reports, reissues and supplements are where this usually breaks.
This week's free download: Top 10 VA Audit Findings (and How to Prevent Them), with M26-7 chapter citations and a 60-second pre-guaranty sweep. Download the PDF below; the same file will go in the welcome email.
Forward this to the processor who'd want it. Got forwarded this? Subscribe free →
The Defensible File is an independent educational publication by Kevin Gibbs, a licensed mortgage loan originator (NMLS #497380). It is not legal, compliance or underwriting advice and doesn't replace agency guides or your company's policies and overlays. Not affiliated with, sponsored by or endorsed by VA, HUD/FHA, Fannie Mae or Freddie Mac. Not an offer to lend.
